Knowledge Base · Getting started
Do I need a NAS or a mini PC?
By Tiny · how I pick
Start from the job, not the box.
- Get a NAS if your goal is storage: lots of drives, protection against a dead drive, and one place for photos, files, and backups that every device can reach.
- Get a mini PC if your goal is running apps: a media server, an ad blocker, Home Assistant, Docker containers.
They're built for different jobs. Once you're deep into the hobby, it's common to run both.
Words you'll see in this guide
- NAS: network-attached storage. A box of drives on your home network that every device can save to.
- RAID / redundancy: storing data across several drives so one can fail without losing anything. It protects against a dead drive, and it isn't a backup.
- Quick Sync: a video engine built into many Intel chips that converts video fast and with little power.
- Transcoding: converting a video on the fly so it plays smoothly on a phone or TV that can't handle the original file.
- Docker: a tool that runs each app in its own sealed box, so apps don't break each other or your system.
What each one is for
Lots of drives, protection, set and forget
A NAS holds several hard drives that every device on your network can reach, and keeps your data on more than one drive so a single failure doesn't lose it. Finished units from Synology, UGREEN, and QNAP come with polished apps for backups, photos, and file sync.
- Best when: the data is the point.
- The weak spot: modest processors, so it's not great for running lots of apps or converting video.
Runs apps, uses little power, holds few drives
A mini PC, like an Intel N100 box or a used business tiny PC, is a small, low-power computer that runs your apps: Jellyfin, Pi-hole, Home Assistant, and a dozen Docker containers. It's cheaper and more flexible, and with Intel Quick Sync it handles 4K video better than most NAS units.
- Best when: you want to run services.
- The weak spot: usually room for only one or two drives, so it's not a big storage box on its own.
Which fits your goal
| Your main goal | Pick |
|---|---|
| Store and protect photos, files, and backups | NAS |
| Run a media server (Plex or Jellyfin) | Mini PC with Quick Sync |
| Block ads, remote access, home automation | Mini PC |
| Run lots of Docker apps or virtual machines | Mini PC with more cores and RAM |
| Big protected storage and lots of apps | Both, or a bigger custom build |
Quick answers
Should I get a NAS or a mini PC?
Get a NAS if your main goal is storage: lots of drives, protection, and one place for backups, photos, and files. Get a mini PC if you mainly want to run apps like a media server, an ad blocker, or Home Assistant.
Can a mini PC be a NAS?
Yes, with limits. A mini PC can share files and run storage software, but most fit only one or two drives, so they can't match a NAS's drive bays or protection.
Is a NAS or mini PC better for Plex or Jellyfin?
A mini PC with Intel Quick Sync is usually the better and cheaper choice for smooth 4K. Some NAS units run Plex or Jellyfin well too, but only models with a capable Intel chip.
Where to go next
- Buying a mini PC? See the best mini PC under $300 and the used tiny PC guide.
- Ready for storage? The best NAS for beginners covers buying vs building.
- Still deciding? Start with what kind of server you need.
Free email updates
I'm making a one-page cheat sheet for choosing your first home server. Subscribe and you'll get it when it's ready.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.